Total Drama Season Ranking
A thank you to America
Keith's Horror Show Episode 11: Silence of the Lambs franchise ranking
WOOOOOO I ACTUALLY DID IT!
Keith's Horror Show Episode 10: Psycho franchise ranking
View All Blogs
Total Drama Season Ranking
Since Total Drama is popping off here today. I got my season ranking for yall
9th (The Worst): Pahkitew Island - It's just not good, it was a close race between this and All Stars but honestly I actually really liked the first 3 episodes of All Stars and nothing this season comes close to anything from that stretch, all the characters are not teen stereotypes it's just stupid stuff they made up on the spot, the writing is awful, the only good characters are Shawn, Jasmine and maybe Max, and while some have grown on me like Ella, Sugar and Topher, it's still not a good season at all.
8th: All Stars - All Stars failed hard and has some weird casting picks (looking at you Sam) but the first 3 episodes are genuinely great and I also love Alejandro's underdog run and the Heather vs Alejandro episode is actually really fun even if Heather was made to be kind of stupid. I actually love some of the comedy, especially with the Blue Harvest Moon episode with Heather and Scott in particular being highlights. So while I agree with every complaint about the season, I find some entertainment in it.
7th: The Reboot Season 2 - the runs of some characters lasting as long as they did annoyed me, I don't love the winner, I don't love the storylines but there are quite a few stand out episodes and the premerge in particular is really strong. It just falls off really hard at the merge.
6th: World Tour - I want to put World Tour higher, the songs are fantastic, some of the stuff is genuinely top tier like the Heather and Alejandro rivalry but they ruined so many characters, so many of the storylines just anger me more than they entertain me, I hated the writing in general this season with some stand out good characters like Noah, Tyler, Alejandro, Heather but then they also ruined like basically everyone else and that really sucks. I love the season for its best qualities, but I hate it for the horrible writing, especially with the love triangle, good God I wanted to die watching that. Overall its a hugely mixed bag of a season but I'm more negative on it than positive.
5th: Revenge of the Island - I know its gonna be seen as insane to put ROTI over World Tour but I genuinely think ROTI is one of the funniest seasons of the show and has a fantastic cast, notably Scott, Jo, Cameron, Brick, Lightning and Zoey being some of my favorites of that season. I genuinely love the storylines like Commando Zoey near the end, Lightning is a top tier character and one of my favorite villains which is a cool storyline, I really loved the comedy, the dynamics, how many characters had hugely villainous moments and the ride was just more consistent than World Tour. The highs of World Tour are much higher but there's not a single genuinely bad episode in the entirety of ROTI so I put it higher.
4th: Reboot Season 1 - A great breath of fresh air, just a really solid season, I don't love all of the characters but there are standouts. I loved that we finally got to see them do a non straight couple, which was cool and the show as a whole is incredibly solid. I just think its nowhere near as memorable to me as these top 3.
3rd: Ridonculus Race - The best and only spinoff because I refuse to accept Dramarama as a real thing. It's the best the show has been after the first two seasons, every duo is memorable in some ways even the earlier boots, I love the cast, I love the format being different than TDI, it was nice to see their take on amazing race and it worked really well. Overall it's a top 3 season for me, while there are some annoying storylines, none of them reach the levels of bad that World Tour has in terms of the worst storylines in the show and even some pairs I hated originally I grew an appreciation for like the daters/haters and the vegans.
2nd: Action - I really wanted to put Action at #1. I think its the funniest season of the show and it's not even close, but the best season is obviously Island in terms of overall quality and so it's gotta be number one for me but I really enjoyed Action on the rewatch, notably seeing characters from Island that weren't given a ton of screen time getting new life here like Beth, Harold, Justin especially. The comedy really carries it for me though, like it's never gonna be as dramatic as Island so it doesn't really try to be, it plays more into the comedy and jokes and I love that direction. Top tier season.
1st: Island - You all probably knew it was coming its just so good, every storyline works, every character is pretty great and none of them have been derailed yet, it's a fantastic season of television and entertainment and actually got me into Survivor and Big Brother when I was younger. I love this season and it'll always have a special place in my heart.
So that was my ranking, thank you all for reading if you did, I'm gonna work on a retrospective series for this where I go even more in depth episode by episode of Total drama maybe later this month, but I thought I'd give my rankings before the rewatch and before I do that retrospective.
3 votes, 35 points


Comments
I really like Scarlett and Samey also from PI besides their boot episodes I was like welp but them really enjoyed them as characters and yeah besides World Tour being higher then me we have very similar taste
okay but whos your top three race teams?
jessiejedi ice dancers, sisters and daters/haters with rockers as an Honorable mention