Favorite brainrot Showgirl criticisms

Amandasings04 8th of October 2025

1. “Taylor didn’t understand what sympathy was a knife was about” and then they explain what the song was about 2. “She wants to have a neighborhood of white people” and being stunned when someone says pretty sure she just wants to have a lot of kids lol 3. Cancelled is about anything but BLAKE LIVELY and how Taylor understands what it’s like to face a public takedown campaign in the media 4. Opalite is about how he used to date a black girl. Not that the night sky is black and Opalite is the damn color of the sky lmfao 5. She’s being sincere in Eldest Daughter first verse 6. This is her worst…. When Lover and Midnights could fucking never make money being pretty and witty 7. She “stole” music because yes we suddenly can own chord progressions and cannot reference things. Stole Lana and Jack’s lyrics “when you know you know” instead of saying they’re in perfect couples bc THEY are the ones who said it I have like 8-15 but I’m getting annoyed writing this. Ok fine #8 is that she bullied charli saying she does coke. Charli literally does do coke so how is that a read

3 votes, 6 points

Comments

Paul there’s something in the air with people being vicious to a legacy pop act putting out music lol eternal sunshine was panned bc Ethan Slater drama, Cowboy Carter made ppl mad because it’s long or something, Man’s best friend offended people for being sexual (as if Taste and Espresso weren’t massive hits last year), Chappell singles not living up to Good Luck Babe/Midwest princess, and now Showgirl is the worst thing ever and Taylor is a conservative propagandist lmfao. They wanna see you rise they don’t want you to reign!

By Amandasings04,

8th of October 2025

evrtngbagel notice how I only said first verse bc you won’t catch me defending “every eldest daughter was the first lamb to the slaughter so we all dressed up like wolves and we looked fire”

By Amandasings04,

8th of October 2025

Posterboy opalite is about how you need to create your own happiness in life. Opalite being man made is the point lol

By Amandasings04,

8th of October 2025

I highly disagree this is her worst album. The lyrics of eldest daughter, hate to say it, is horrible. However, the rest of the album is sooooo catchy

By evrtngbagel,

8th of October 2025

I do think it's her worst album by far, specifically the lyrics. The concept of Opalite being made in a lab and not a real gem found in nature. Onyx symbolizing strength and grounding... idk what she was trying to say with that. Remember, self-proclaimed English teacher!

By PosterBoy,

8th of October 2025

mind you the life of a showgirl the best out of the recent pop albums!

By Paul,

8th of October 2025