DNTM AI Scoring
I asked AI to take a stab at judging this week. It feels like a cool idea since it is an AI competition to let AI take over. I fed it the exact prompt, and told it to judge it like a modeling competition. Because it put my photo first, I edited the prompt to include a note to not favor any image in particular, especially not any that it knows I had a hand in making (I have obviously done my own photo but it also has seen me work on other model's photos in the past for fun when I do my critique blogs). I told it to judge as if seeing all pictures for the first time and rank them without bias. It included a chart with the scores, and some details about each (more details for top photos). It also gave details about its scoring rubric.
RUBRIC
If I were judging this as a Top Model competition, I'd weight the score more heavily toward the model than the overall artwork.
Scoring Rubric (100 points)
Modeling & Pose (40) – Editorial posing, body awareness, elongation, tension, interaction with the moon.
Fashion & Styling (25) – Garment, styling, makeup, accessories, couture quality.
Prompt Execution (20) – Is the moon clearly the centerpiece and integrated into the pose?
Editorial Impact (15) – Does it look like a high-fashion campaign rather than fantasy art?
🥇 1st — Goomybear
Score: 97/100
Modeling: 39/40
This is the strongest modeling performance in the set.
Excellent asymmetry.
Beautiful angular body lines.
Strong hand placement.
Direct gaze creates presence.
Fashion: 24/25
Styling is memorable and cohesive.
The wolf motif feels like couture rather than costume.
Prompt: 19/20
Very strong interaction with the moon.
The moon remains a dominant compositional element.
Editorial: 15/15
Feels like a luxury fashion campaign.
Instantly recognizable.
Why #1: If I were judging only the model's performance, this would receive my highest score.
🥈 2nd — Marquis
Score: 96/100
Modeling: 38/40
Elegant body line.
Long neck.
Beautiful shoulder placement.
Sophisticated hand positioning.
Fashion: 25/25
Possibly the strongest garment in the competition.
Prompt: 19/20
Excellent moon interaction.
Editorial: 14/15
Extremely polished.
Slightly safer than Goomy.
Why #2: More couture than almost anyone else, but the modeling has a little less tension than Goomy.
🥉 3rd — Lewis
Score: 94/100
Modeling: 36/40
Excellent face.
Beautiful extension.
Reclining pose is elegant but doesn't create as much dynamic energy.
Fashion: 25/25
Spectacular styling.
Prompt: 18/20
Moon is central.
Interaction is convincing.
Editorial: 15/15
Looks expensive.
4th —Honey
Score: 93/100
Modeling: 37/40
Lovely elongated body.
Natural elegance.
Fashion: 23/25
Prompt: 18/20
Editorial: 15/15
The reflection elevates this considerably.
5th — KaliMinaj
Score: 92/100
Great hand placement.
Excellent storytelling.
Fashion styling is softer than the top entries.
6th — AngieKStan
Score: 91/100
Very polished.
Beautiful garment.
Pose is fairly conventional compared to the leaders.
7th — GuiltyAsSin
Score: 90/100
Fantastic silhouette.
However...
The model barely interacts with the moon.
It almost becomes scenery.
8th — Manyomash
Score: 90/100
Beautiful styling.
Strong fashion.
The pose feels more illustrative than editorial.
9th — CupidStunt
Score: 89/100
Very creative.
Good storytelling.
The telescope becomes almost as important as the model.
10th — Maris
Score: 88/100
Very beautiful.
However the pose is passive.
The mood is dreamy more than fashion.
11th — Fancy
Score: 87/100
Excellent pose.
Unfortunately it reads more science-fiction than couture.
12th — Medusaluh
Score: 86/100
Interesting.
Fashion leans costume.
The moon feels more decorative than integrated into the theme.
13th — Seong
Score: 83/100
Beautiful mood.
Minimal modeling.
Little interaction with the moon.
Feels more like a portrait.
RUBRIC
If I were judging this as a Top Model competition, I'd weight the score more heavily toward the model than the overall artwork.
Scoring Rubric (100 points)
Modeling & Pose (40) – Editorial posing, body awareness, elongation, tension, interaction with the moon.
Fashion & Styling (25) – Garment, styling, makeup, accessories, couture quality.
Prompt Execution (20) – Is the moon clearly the centerpiece and integrated into the pose?
Editorial Impact (15) – Does it look like a high-fashion campaign rather than fantasy art?
🥇 1st — Goomybear
Score: 97/100
Modeling: 39/40
This is the strongest modeling performance in the set.
Excellent asymmetry.
Beautiful angular body lines.
Strong hand placement.
Direct gaze creates presence.
Fashion: 24/25
Styling is memorable and cohesive.
The wolf motif feels like couture rather than costume.
Prompt: 19/20
Very strong interaction with the moon.
The moon remains a dominant compositional element.
Editorial: 15/15
Feels like a luxury fashion campaign.
Instantly recognizable.
Why #1: If I were judging only the model's performance, this would receive my highest score.
🥈 2nd — Marquis
Score: 96/100
Modeling: 38/40
Elegant body line.
Long neck.
Beautiful shoulder placement.
Sophisticated hand positioning.
Fashion: 25/25
Possibly the strongest garment in the competition.
Prompt: 19/20
Excellent moon interaction.
Editorial: 14/15
Extremely polished.
Slightly safer than Goomy.
Why #2: More couture than almost anyone else, but the modeling has a little less tension than Goomy.
🥉 3rd — Lewis
Score: 94/100
Modeling: 36/40
Excellent face.
Beautiful extension.
Reclining pose is elegant but doesn't create as much dynamic energy.
Fashion: 25/25
Spectacular styling.
Prompt: 18/20
Moon is central.
Interaction is convincing.
Editorial: 15/15
Looks expensive.
4th —Honey
Score: 93/100
Modeling: 37/40
Lovely elongated body.
Natural elegance.
Fashion: 23/25
Prompt: 18/20
Editorial: 15/15
The reflection elevates this considerably.
5th — KaliMinaj
Score: 92/100
Great hand placement.
Excellent storytelling.
Fashion styling is softer than the top entries.
6th — AngieKStan
Score: 91/100
Very polished.
Beautiful garment.
Pose is fairly conventional compared to the leaders.
7th — GuiltyAsSin
Score: 90/100
Fantastic silhouette.
However...
The model barely interacts with the moon.
It almost becomes scenery.
8th — Manyomash
Score: 90/100
Beautiful styling.
Strong fashion.
The pose feels more illustrative than editorial.
9th — CupidStunt
Score: 89/100
Very creative.
Good storytelling.
The telescope becomes almost as important as the model.
10th — Maris
Score: 88/100
Very beautiful.
However the pose is passive.
The mood is dreamy more than fashion.
11th — Fancy
Score: 87/100
Excellent pose.
Unfortunately it reads more science-fiction than couture.
12th — Medusaluh
Score: 86/100
Interesting.
Fashion leans costume.
The moon feels more decorative than integrated into the theme.
13th — Seong
Score: 83/100
Beautiful mood.
Minimal modeling.
Little interaction with the moon.
Feels more like a portrait.
11 votes, 13 points
Comments
and didn’t gpt give my photo the win last week too?! my favorite judge wbk
Marquis Yes you were scored highly last week by Chat.
This is fun!
Nora agreed. Even when it had me placed lower in other weeks I liked it. I think since it’s an AI game it makes sense to include an AI judge. Maybe AI is like one judge on the panel with other human judges in the future?
What a coincidence the chatgpt that made your picture likes it the best LOL
CupidStunt I have done this each round and it was not first in other rounds. But to be sure that's why I added all the extra prompting to make sure it wasn't being biased. Obviously still a chance it is but I told it not to like 5 or 6 different ways and it didn't change the order this time.
Well at least someone appreciated my photo, thanks Chat GPT
I have try this too . ChatGPT gives different result in others users ( I had try it with some friends a lot times ) it’s fun
Dimitra I figured. I would want to use a completely unrelated account. But I did it like 5-6 different ways of insuring it didn't favor images. I also tried to manually override the scoring criteria it chose and that completely changed the ranks and it scored me lower so I know it wasn't just favoring my image. I did this for other rounds and it had my photo much lower as well (rightly so).
Goomybear Yeah, it always gives different results. Sometimes the exact same prompt will rank a photo first, and later it’ll rank that same photo last. But it’s still fun to mess around with.
Dimitra but what I like about this format is that if gives the weight% of how it is judging, and that it scores each photo in each category. It removes personal taste from it and just goes on the criteria. This would not have been my order (I would not be first, Medusa wouldn't be that low, and others would be changed as well)